Address the following questions in your post: What do you think about the arguments

Address the following questions in your post: What do you think about the arguments of the parties in each side of this case?  Be specific when answering! What do you think about the ruling in this case? 
 
Post your initial response (100 words minimum), then read and respond to at least one classmate (50 words minimum). You won’t be able to see your classmate’s responses until after your initial post.